| Big Book of Model Railroad Track Plans |  | Author: Bob Schleicher
Publisher: MBI
Category: Book
List Price: $34.95
Buy Used: $31.15
as of 7/31/2010 19:00 CDT details
You Save: $3.80 (11%)
New (5) Used (16) from $31.15
Seller: goldengatetreasure
Rating:  5 reviews
Sales Rank: 774,840
Media: Paperback
Pages: 272
Number Of Items: 1
Shipping Weight (lbs): 2.4
Dimensions (in): 10.5 x 8.3 x 0.7
ISBN: 0760314233
Dewey Decimal Number: 625.19
EAN: 9780760314234
ASIN: 0760314233
Publication Date: July 25, 2003
Availability: Usually ships in 1-2 business days
| |
| Similar Items:
| |
| Editorial Reviews:
Product Description
For the model train hobbyist, this incredibly detailed book features 81 model track plan options. Each project description includes technical advice and prototype photos that will inspire any model railroad enthusiast. Projects feature likely obstacles that might be encountered during construction and helpful tips for getting it right the first time. Line art diagrams, layout routes, dimensions, and even photographs of the finished layout are included. The book is organized into six sections The Best Plans for Your First Layout, Shelf Style Layouts, Bedroom-Size Track Plans, Track Plans for Larger Spaces, Staging Yards and Holdover Tracks, and Modular Model Railroad Plans.
|
| Customer Reviews:
 Good book for ideas, but hard to actually build one October 29, 2009
Peter M. Eick (Houston, Texas United States)
The book is good for general ideas, but I would not try to use it for any of the larger then say 4x8 plans. I would have liked more plans and careful layouts in normal spaces. You don't get this with this book. I did end up snagging a few ideas here and there for my own plan though.
 Not necessarily what it seems... December 21, 2007
Gregory Hargreaves (Bozeman, MT USA)
This book does contain a multitude of track plans. The plans overall, however, tend to be sub-par. This is most evident when you compare this book to those written by the Late John Armstrong, or the track plans published in hobby magizines.
The book is helpfull, however, in planning for staging operations and seeing how one can best ultilize avalible space. It is a good book if one is just getting started in the hobby, and needs some ideas to start from. More advanced model railroaders may only get mild amusment from the book.
Disappointing October 26, 2005
Casey Jones (Harrisburg, PA USA)
8 out of 9 found this review helpful
Many of my issues with this book were covered in another review. Most of the "plans" are really just a couple tracks. The diagrams aren't clear enough for a book on track planning (for a magazine writeup, maybe, for a book of plans for practical use, no). The plans are repetitive and derivative of each other. And, as previously noted, there is very little breadth of offering - over and over you see the same format of layout: for instance if you have any significant-size space but don't want a multi-deck layout, you're out of luck.
It's not 101 layouts, it's 101 variations on 2-4 basic ideas...
 Very good January 26, 2005
A train fan
7 out of 9 found this review helpful
An excellent book about designing a small to medium layout. Many track planning books assume that we all have huge basements and rarely focus on smaller spaces, like a spare bedroom.
At first glance, a number of the plans seem similar. When you study them closer it becomes clear how a plan can be transformed by adding an around-the-wall shelf or changing a part of it. I think this sort of evolutionary designing gives a lot more insight into the design process.
The shelf layouts are nice and show how you can build a layout in a very compact space. They look more like British designs, which usually have a visible station and some staging sidings.
The room-size layouts pack a lot into a modest room. By adding a second deck the operations are substantially increased albeit at the cost of more complex construction. There is a relation between the space and the amount of model railroad that we want to fit in. If you want to squeeze in more mainline run in a small space, sooner or later you have to consider multidecking. It's up to the reader to decide if the extra effort is worth the trouble.
This brings me to the observation that most plans in this book feature point-to-point type operation. The emphasis is on smaller lines like shortlines, logging railroads or secondary lines of larger railroads. A logical choice as this sort of railroad is far better suited for a small room than trying to model the Union Pacfic mainline in HO in a 9x9 room. If this isn't your cup of tea then this book is probably not for you.
 Disapointed November 23, 2003
32 out of 34 found this review helpful
Very disapointing to say the least. THE BIG BOOK OF MODEL RAILROAD TRACK PLANS boasts "99 complete plans", I beg to differ. I accept the fact that many people do not have the room for large class-1 type railroad layouts, but many of the "shelf" plans are little more than a place to display your scenery talents and some rolling stock, nothing that could accurately be described as operational.Moving on to the larger layout plans, it doesn't get any better. They all seem to be based on just a few basic designs with only minor changes like an additional siding or where the railroad is based in the world. You're left with the feeling of "if you've seen one, you've seen them all." Another point to consider is, not everyone wants to build a multi-level or spiral layout to gain operational ability. I also don't think that most people want a design that requires a turntable or wye at each end. If they do, then there's plenty to be happy about. Most of the plans seem suited to small steam powered logging railroads or for someone with a huge imagination to fill in the blanks. It isn't my desire to bash anybody, but at least in my case, it didn't even offer a fresh idea. Mr. Schleicher's book, "Building your next model railroad" offers many good tips and ideas on the actual building of a layout, but this book is a real let down. My advice is to look elsewhere.
|
|
|
CERTAIN CONTENT THAT APPEARS ON THIS SITE COMES FROM AMAZON SERVICES LLC. THIS CONTENT IS PROVIDED ‘AS IS’ AND IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE OR REMOVAL AT ANY TIME.
Copyright 2009 - RailroadBookstore.com | |
